Tuesday, February 07, 2006

Not So Simple Media Lessons: Tact and Wisdom

From China to Denmark, Media Lessons

Please consider this commentary on the C.S. Monitor regarding the need for tact and wisdom while exercising freedom of expression.

Pointing to the examples of Google in China and the incendiary "Muhammad Cartoons" from Denmark--which "have more in common than 2.7 million search hits the phrase produced"--it is evident that such freedom demands the absolute maturity to use it wisely and responsibly. While the grave consequences were surely not anticipated, they were wholly avoidable. What response did the cartoonist expect from his caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad? Controversy, perhaps, but violence and the burning of Danish flags and their embassy, certainly not. Was printing such a provocative cartoon the most productive way of making a commentary, creating discussion, encouraging a change in mindsets about the Muslim community as a whole which has felt the onslaught from both within and without? While the repercussions from this latest media faux-pas have escalated beyond control, at best it will *hopefully* serve to make both the media industry and individual journalists more accountable in their reporting and publishing.

Given such irresponsible behavior, it is no wonder media journalists in Turkey are under incredible surveillance and being brought before the state judicial system. Unfortunately in this case, it is for their responsible reporting.

4 Comments:

Blogger Simon said...

Freedom comes with responsibility, doesn't it?

What I want to know is, if no-one living has ever seen him or a picture of him, how does anyone know it is a cartoon depicting Muhammad?

11:48 AM, February 07, 2006  
Blogger Kathryn Soraya Khamsi said...

Likewise. If the caption had not made reference to His identity, then I would have never thought of the depiction being that of the Prophet Muhammad. But, still the intention is what is important here. If it were not Muhammad, would it still be okay? I venture to suggest, not.

11:57 AM, February 07, 2006  
Blogger Free Lenny said...

However ill-considered the printing of such cartoons may have been, the fact is that a cartoon or statement is not the same thing as a violent act. If freedom of speech is limited only to those statements that do not offend, then anyone holding power through force can prevent political criticism.
Religious fanatics of all faiths champion the imposition of thought-controlling theocracies, which cannot tolerate freedom of speech.

7:38 AM, February 13, 2006  
Blogger Kathryn Soraya Khamsi said...

I hear you! A blog posting to come on that soon....

3:23 PM, February 15, 2006  

Post a Comment

<< Home